THE RULES!! AN EXCITING NEW THREAD!!

[Mark S]

Andrei Kanchelskis (But void question as it is not on THE RULES!!)

Back to PUNKISDEAD

[PUNKISDEAD]

Very true mark, the question was not about THE RULES, I thank you for your stewardship in my absence, and as a reward bestow on you the honor of posing the next question

PS. Hope your party went well, soz that i did nt make it, i was rockin at hyde park festival

[PUNKISDEAD]

Looks like it is down to me then

If a goalkeeper, who decides to change places with one of his team mates without notifying the referee , handles the ball inside the penalty area, what action should the referee take

[outsider]

no action can be taken, as nobody apart from the goal keeper knew about it

[Number 1]

Looks like it is down to me then

If a goalkeeper, who decides to change places with one of his team mates without notifying the referee , handles the ball inside the penalty area, what action should the referee take

It would be a penalty, because reading the question literally, it would mean that the goalkeeper is now an outfield player and therefore not entitled to handle it anyway.

[bigreddog]

The ref would wave play on as the goalkeeper is the goalkeeper until the ref either allows a sub or change of position.

[ezz]

The world would end therefore the answer will never be known.......looks like its the end of this thread as we know it

[heysham_mfc]

the ref would play on as he he still the goalkeeper even if he is plsying in an outfield position

[PUNKISDEAD]

Number 1 is correct and has earned the honor of posing the next question on this very popular and entertaining thread

[shrimper]

Number 1 is correct:

No he isn't. Justify that statement. Otherwise, sir, I challenge you to a duel at dawn!

A goalkeeper is not allowed arbitrarily to 'switch positions' with a team-mate, it's not running keepers!

If he has informed the referee and the switch has been made formally, then Number 1 would be correct but that wasn't what you said.

You're just throwing things in the dark.

[Mark S]

You're just throwing things in the dark.

[outsider]

i also object as i was the first who said that as nobody knew nothing would be done!




That's it its not fair i am not playing anymore..................... where's me ball?

[Number 1]

Given that it's the question master who decides who is right, I claim the right to pose the next question.

A goalkeeper takes a goal kick on a very windy day. In fact, it's so windy that when the goal kick is taken, the ball doesn't even leave the penalty area but blows back into the goal.

What's the decision?

[bigreddog]

ooh ooh I know this one. The ref has to give a corner because you cant score direct from a goal kick, but the ball has gone out of play.

I'm out for the rest of the evening, so if this is right feel free to carry on without me.

[james456]

Given that it's the question master who decides who is right, I claim the right to pose the next question.

A goalkeeper takes a goal kick on a very windy day. In fact, it's so windy that when the goal kick is taken, the ball doesn't even leave the penalty area but blows back into the goal.

What's the decision?

Its still a goal?

I don't understand how it could be anything else.

[Mark S]

Goal! It left the penalty area when it crossed the goal line.

[outsider]

Given that it's the question master who decides who is right, I claim the right to pose the next question.

A goalkeeper takes a goal kick on a very windy day. In fact, it's so windy that when the goal kick is taken, the ball doesn't even leave the penalty area but blows back into the goal.

What's the decision?

Its still a goal?

I don't understand how it could be anything else.

no goal retake the goal kick

[Number 1]

Given that it's the question master who decides who is right, I claim the right to pose the next question.

A goalkeeper takes a goal kick on a very windy day. In fact, it's so windy that when the goal kick is taken, the ball doesn't even leave the penalty area but blows back into the goal.

What's the decision?

Its still a goal?

I don't understand how it could be anything else.

no goal retake the goal kick

Correct. The key was that it hasn't left the penalty area so it's retaken.

[outsider]

What is the maximum width of the pitch markings?

[heysham_mfc]

;)

What is the maximum width of the pitch markings?

6 cm

[outsider]

nope

[PUNKISDEAD]

Does this mean the width of the pitch

or the markings

[outsider]

Does this mean the width of the pitch

or the markings

the actual maximum width of the markings

[PUNKISDEAD]

Is it 5 inches

[outsider]

All lines must be of the same width, which must be not more than
12 cm (5 ins).

so yup well done